condude1 wrote:Alright!
So, I'm doing every challenge I can. It sounds like fun, and I see no downside. I will, however, wait to submit a guess until tonight, considering that someone may come in with a stroke of genius that sways me.
Is there any reason we'd expect tracking to work here? If the mafia can just lie, making a plan doesn't really help anyone, right?
This was pretty much my thinking before the game started.
Got to ask people more familiar with Condude if this seems normal town Condude. I ask specifically because from the very little I've seen of him (and I really count last game for less because I was scum there so didn't really
have to solve him), he strikes me as someone who is more likely than someone like me to be bold and somewhat controversial or something to open things up. If that makes any sense. Like the way he went after Don for just seeming to be too wishy washy or fluffy to start that last game. Maybe he does that because in his mind it's more townie and he's more likely as town to really go out on a limb. And the way he was very argumentative about some mechanics stuff in that game.
But anyway, his thoughts here were pretty much the way I was thinking of approaching the challenges in general. Like even down to asking if anyone else had any problems with it that he hadn't considered before. If I'd made it to thread before Condude I'd have said the same thing more or less.
Were you assuming that some kind of tracking thing would work? How did you think that might be a thing here? There wasn't really anything that made me think that in the rules. But I know you tend to see things mechanically in ways I usually don't immediately.
Aeschines wrote:I'm psyched! My plan is also to do as many challenges as I can. I'm excited to see what the status effects are!
Lol oh man now I have to actually try to read Aes again.
nanooktheeskimo wrote:Doesn’t look like there’s a way to track who does each challenge, at least not the first one, so I’m going to guess that either this one isn’t the one that matters or there won’t be a way to track most if not all of the challenges.
So yeah see no downside to everyone doing this one, since presumably scum can just lie and do it anyways.
Did you have thoughts that there would be a way to track who does each challenge? Or was this mainly a response to Condude?
One thought I did have when seeing this specific Chubby Bunny challenge. We have to guess how many of the smaller ones she was able to do this with. So can we assume that whoever gets closer gets some kind of specific benefit? Like maybe a vig shot or cop check or something?
(now gifted to its rightful owner)
