Moderator: mjparrett
The communication we got was that he requested a sub. Things could well be different going forward.
boldblade wrote:jay65536 wrote:
You mean the one where he correctly threw a solo because someone stupidly tried to cut him out of the draw? I don't see anything wrong with that one. Whose idea was it to stab him when it was within his power to throw a solo?
Indeed I suspect that is the one V was criticizing.
V wrote:Indeed an great solo opportunity. Looks like the round 3 solo rate could be excellent.
V wrote:boldblade wrote:jay65536 wrote:
You mean the one where he correctly threw a solo because someone stupidly tried to cut him out of the draw? I don't see anything wrong with that one. Whose idea was it to stab him when it was within his power to throw a solo?
Indeed I suspect that is the one V was criticizing.
Yeah, that’s the one I had in mind.
If you check order history there was no effective attack in progress on Russia & in fact the diplomacy at end game, centred around Russia reluctantly accepting there would be no further whittling of Germany, or England, so the likely result became a 5-way (definitely including Russia). I’m sure for some it was not considered the preferred outcome, but as far as I know everyone appeared reconciled (with no obvious alternative).
Then he supported Italy into a German SC & screwed up, throwing the game. I never stated the kingmaking was necessarily intentional (hell, I don’t know what he was thinking at the time) but I’m not sure it being accidental is a saving grace, or an even bigger indictment.
There was no stab on Russia, motivating & justifying him throwing the game, he just screwed up. As he just did as Turkey in round 3.
jimbobicus wrote:2. I'm not sure what this thread is even doing here? We shouldn't be discussing games while they are still continuing. I know this may seem ironic coming from the person who has been kicked out the game for breaking site rules. Although, in my defence, I didn't know that I was breaking the rules - and it seems an odd rule anyway. I'm sure there'd be lots of people here who have allowed family members or friends to see their games, contribute their thoughts etc and perhaps even play while they are on holiday or at times when they are too busy. As long as none of these friends or family have their own accounts on the site and are potential opponents, then I'm not seeing what the big issue was there. Although the mods disagreed - so presumably I'm missing something here. Also I won't complain too much - for the reasons already stated, I'm happy to be out.
Return to PlayDip Diplomacy League
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest