Page 3 of 3

Re: Nomic 5 Proposal 305 - Amendment to 206 - F.A.R.T. Act

PostPosted: 04 Mar 2014, 21:50
by super_dipsy
[size=150]NAY[/size]

Sorry not to vote earlier, been tied up all day. I am voting nay because I like to leave all options open. Rather than stop people posting rule changes like 'I win' I prefer the view that people should watch out for the implications and pitfalls of various proposals,

I seem to be the last to vote, so I guess I need to do the scoring.

Ayes = 2 (Ugluk, Zoomzip)
Nays = 4 (Connect4, Pagane, Crunkus, Dipsy)

Proposal 305 fails.

I think the scoring is as follows:

Ugluk receives:- (305-291)*2/6 = +5 (rounded to nearest integer (rule 203) and -10 for a failed proposal (207)
Total is -5.

This gives a new scorecard as
Connect4 - 9
Crunkus - 11
Pagane - -4
super_dipsy - 8
Ugluk - -5
Zoomzip - 0

This posting ends the turn (301 a 1)

Zoomzip, all yours!

Re: Nomic 5 Proposal 305 - Amendment to 206 - F.A.R.T. Act

PostPosted: 04 Mar 2014, 21:53
by super_dipsy
Bit premature of me since my vote did not format properly. So since I have not voted yet,

NAY

Sorry not to vote earlier, been tied up all day. I am voting nay because I like to leave all options open. Rather than stop people posting rule changes like 'I win' I prefer the view that people should watch out for the implications and pitfalls of various proposals,

I seem to be the last to vote, so I guess I need to do the scoring.

Ayes = 2 (Ugluk, Zoomzip)
Nays = 4 (Connect4, Pagane, Crunkus, Dipsy)

Proposal 305 fails.

I think the scoring is as follows:

Ugluk receives:- (305-291)*2/6 = +5 (rounded to nearest integer (rule 203) and -10 for a failed proposal (207)
Total is -5.

This gives a new scorecard as
Connect4 - 9
Crunkus - 11
Pagane - -4
super_dipsy - 8
Ugluk - -5
Zoomzip - 0

This posting ends the turn (301 a 1)

Zoomzip, all yours.