Page 113 of 115

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:22
by RedSun
Keirador wrote:
JoeHoya06 (5): Keirador, kimbyrle(+1), RedSun, nanooktheeskimo
RedSun (4): Telleo, UpsideDownChuck, JoeHoya06(+1)

It deeply sucks that Tellers' vote is where it is without commentary on Red Sun's reveal. I think on principle I want to be on the other side of it.

Plus it feels right to let it all come down to the wrasslin'.


Has me and Joe's fight happened yet?

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:22
by kimpossible
nanooktheeskimo wrote:Keir, I'm kind of struggling to understand your 180 on me here--is it solely because I didn't react to RS' reveal the way you think I should have?* or is it more POE (you buy RS' reveal, Kim is tonally town, therefore it's down to me/Telleo/Joe, although I'm not certain I understand why you flipped your position on me/Joe other than Joe being here today and me not)?



*I would argue that without the knowledge of RS being removed from play tomorrow if his VC is met, it was entirely reasonable to see an essentially last minute 3p claim as quite possibly being a scum low risk high reward play. I see where you're coming from on that, but I don't think it's nearly as indicative either way--as scum, I'm probably agreeing with it and letting it pass, because either Joe is town and I don't care, or Joe is scum and I want credit for helping kill him. But that's easier for me to know how I'd play it than you.

Guessing you haven't read everything I wrote in the last 48 hours. I've been on a Joe lynch since yesterday. I'm simply examining the combinations in hopes of finding whatever seems the most likely. You and Joe could make sense, but it has a lot of holes in it. Joe and Telleo could make sense. And I continually come back to "I don't understand the shit you've done if you're scum."

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:22
by kimpossible
RedSun wrote:
Keirador wrote:
JoeHoya06 (5): Keirador, kimbyrle(+1), RedSun, nanooktheeskimo
RedSun (4): Telleo, UpsideDownChuck, JoeHoya06(+1)

It deeply sucks that Tellers' vote is where it is without commentary on Red Sun's reveal. I think on principle I want to be on the other side of it.

Plus it feels right to let it all come down to the wrasslin'.


Has me and Joe's fight happened yet?

Yep. You lost. He has 3 votes now.

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:23
by kimpossible
kimbyrle wrote:
nanooktheeskimo wrote:Keir, I'm kind of struggling to understand your 180 on me here--is it solely because I didn't react to RS' reveal the way you think I should have?* or is it more POE (you buy RS' reveal, Kim is tonally town, therefore it's down to me/Telleo/Joe, although I'm not certain I understand why you flipped your position on me/Joe other than Joe being here today and me not)?



*I would argue that without the knowledge of RS being removed from play tomorrow if his VC is met, it was entirely reasonable to see an essentially last minute 3p claim as quite possibly being a scum low risk high reward play. I see where you're coming from on that, but I don't think it's nearly as indicative either way--as scum, I'm probably agreeing with it and letting it pass, because either Joe is town and I don't care, or Joe is scum and I want credit for helping kill him. But that's easier for me to know how I'd play it than you.

Guessing you haven't read everything I wrote in the last 48 hours. I've been on a Joe lynch since yesterday. I'm simply examining the combinations in hopes of finding whatever seems the most likely. You and Joe could make sense, but it has a lot of holes in it. Joe and Telleo could make sense. And I continually come back to "I don't understand the shit you've done if you're scum."

Shit, you weren't talking to me. I saw "K name" and responded.

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:24
by Nanook
kimbyrle wrote:
nanooktheeskimo wrote:Keir, I'm kind of struggling to understand your 180 on me here--is it solely because I didn't react to RS' reveal the way you think I should have?* or is it more POE (you buy RS' reveal, Kim is tonally town, therefore it's down to me/Telleo/Joe, although I'm not certain I understand why you flipped your position on me/Joe other than Joe being here today and me not)?



*I would argue that without the knowledge of RS being removed from play tomorrow if his VC is met, it was entirely reasonable to see an essentially last minute 3p claim as quite possibly being a scum low risk high reward play. I see where you're coming from on that, but I don't think it's nearly as indicative either way--as scum, I'm probably agreeing with it and letting it pass, because either Joe is town and I don't care, or Joe is scum and I want credit for helping kill him. But that's easier for me to know how I'd play it than you.

Guessing you haven't read everything I wrote in the last 48 hours. I've been on a Joe lynch since yesterday. I'm simply examining the combinations in hopes of finding whatever seems the most likely. You and Joe could make sense, but it has a lot of holes in it. Joe and Telleo could make sense. And I continually come back to "I don't understand the shit you've done if you're scum."

I'm guessing you haven't read everything I wrote either ;)

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:24
by Keirador
kimbyrle wrote:But think about this. If it's Nook we're back to "Why would he reveal these things?" Does a Joe/Telleo team make sense? It could, right? Like, they've avoided each other all game, I think? I'm not in a position to dive back through it now, maybe you have time Keir.

If Red's 3P and I'm reading both you and Nook right for the stuff you've done that makes no sense as scum, then we have our dipole scumteam.

Yeah, maybe also explains Joe's sangfroid in the face of Red Sun revealing in a way that probably kills him. He doesn't see his own survival as that awfully essential to his VC.

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:26
by kimpossible
Keirador wrote:
kimbyrle wrote:But think about this. If it's Nook we're back to "Why would he reveal these things?" Does a Joe/Telleo team make sense? It could, right? Like, they've avoided each other all game, I think? I'm not in a position to dive back through it now, maybe you have time Keir.

If Red's 3P and I'm reading both you and Nook right for the stuff you've done that makes no sense as scum, then we have our dipole scumteam.

Yeah, maybe also explains Joe's sangfroid in the face of Red Sun revealing in a way that probably kills him. He doesn't see his own survival as that awfully essential to his VC.

Image

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:26
by Keirador
nanooktheeskimo wrote:Keir, I'm kind of struggling to understand your 180 on me here--is it solely because I didn't react to RS' reveal the way you think I should have?* or is it more POE (you buy RS' reveal, Kim is tonally town, therefore it's down to me/Telleo/Joe, although I'm not certain I understand why you flipped your position on me/Joe other than Joe being here today and me not)?



*I would argue that without the knowledge of RS being removed from play tomorrow if his VC is met, it was entirely reasonable to see an essentially last minute 3p claim as quite possibly being a scum low risk high reward play. I see where you're coming from on that, but I don't think it's nearly as indicative either way--as scum, I'm probably agreeing with it and letting it pass, because either Joe is town and I don't care, or Joe is scum and I want credit for helping kill him. But that's easier for me to know how I'd play it than you.

It's not Joe being here, it's how he reacted to RS's reveal vs. how you reacted to RS's reveal. But, it's not enough for me to toss my reads from the rest of the game.

Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:32
by kimpossible
Gotta run. Godspeed all.


Re: Main Event Mafia: Game Thread (Day 3)

PostPosted: 27 Feb 2018, 01:32
by kimpossible
I don't know why my video didn't embed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5zGkqAWsWE