Mafia CLXI: A Completely Normal Game of Mafia - Scum Win!

[Strategus]

At least I'm making and effort.

So am I.

[Strategus]

Actually, I've been on record as being suspicious of you to some degree most days. I've just been willing to overlook it or write it off as new town until today, because your play yesterday and today looks scummier than Shadow and condude's do.

Read my ISO. Me thinking you could be scum shouldn't be surprising, not should me being willing to vote you today if I don't think Shadow is scum (which I no longer do).

This is the first time you have really come away from someone you had targeted. You were dead set on Shadow being scum, and now you have given that up to vote on me, when you are still not sure about me and you are willing to exclude Shadow on a POE, after all the evidence you presented against her? Smells wrong to me.

[Nanook]

Actually, I've been on record as being suspicious of you to some degree most days. I've just been willing to overlook it or write it off as new town until today, because your play yesterday and today looks scummier than Shadow and condude's do.

Read my ISO. Me thinking you could be scum shouldn't be surprising, not should me being willing to vote you today if I don't think Shadow is scum (which I no longer do).

This is the first time you have really come away from someone you had targeted. You were dead set on Shadow being scum, and now you have given that up to vote on me, when you are still not sure about me and you are willing to exclude Shadow on a POE, after all the evidence you presented against her? Smells wrong to me.

Evidence that I backed off of when it was shown to not be as strong as I thought it was. I'm willing to admit when I'm wrong, and while she might be scum, the reasons I had for thinking she was scum didn't hold quite as much water as I thought they did.

I refuse to take heat for backing away from what was, in retrospect, not a very strong case. Especially from you of all people, who were giving me town points for it not even 24 hours ago, for fucks sake! If you want to ding me for the case itself, fine, but I refuse to accept criticism for backing away from a mediocre case that wasn't as strong as I thought it was as initially.

[Nanook]

At least I'm making and effort.

So am I.

[Nanook]

Don't be a dick.

No need for that.

I agree there's no need for it. Hence why I told you not to be one. Because I will be a dick right back, and that's not productive for anyone.

[Strategus]

Actually, I've been on record as being suspicious of you to some degree most days. I've just been willing to overlook it or write it off as new town until today, because your play yesterday and today looks scummier than Shadow and condude's do.

Read my ISO. Me thinking you could be scum shouldn't be surprising, not should me being willing to vote you today if I don't think Shadow is scum (which I no longer do).

This is the first time you have really come away from someone you had targeted. You were dead set on Shadow being scum, and now you have given that up to vote on me, when you are still not sure about me and you are willing to exclude Shadow on a POE, after all the evidence you presented against her? Smells wrong to me.

Evidence that I backed off of when it was shown to not be as strong as I thought it was. I'm willing to admit when I'm wrong, and while she might be scum, the reasons I had for thinking she was scum didn't hold quite as much water as I thought they did.

I refuse to take heat for backing away from what was, in retrospect, not a very strong case. Especially from you of all people, who were giving me town points for it not even 24 hours ago, for fucks sake! If you want to ding me for the case itself, fine, but I refuse to accept criticism for backing away from a mediocre case that wasn't as strong as I thought it was as initially.

That was before you voted for me, when you know I am town. Like I think you knew Joe was town and shadow is town. That just changed things for me.

[Nanook]

So for clarity's sake, your case against me is my voting record?

[Strategus]

So for clarity's sake, your case against me is my voting record?

No, it's your vote against me that has changed things for me. You shouldn't have voted for me if you are town, as you know damn well I am town.

[Nanook]

So for clarity's sake, your case against me is my voting record?

No, it's your vote against me that has changed things for me. You shouldn't have voted for me if you are town, as you know damn well I am town.

And how in the hell does that make sense???! The only way I know you're town, is if I'm scum.

[Strategus]

So for clarity's sake, your case against me is my voting record?

No, it's your vote against me that has changed things for me. You shouldn't have voted for me if you are town, as you know damn well I am town.

And how in the hell does that make sense???! The only way I know you're town, is if I'm scum.

You've been reading me (correctly) as town all the way through the game. If you were town, you knew for sure after I intervened between you and Joe, and you backed off shadow as soon as I did the same. And anyway, I am saying you are mafia, so that's the obvious reason right now.