Page 17 of 18

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 20:34
by nickjb3
If you don't want to die metallord give us a good reason not to kill you.

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 20:36
by Flatley
Nick, I got a good reason not to kill Metallord99: the game will last longer if we don't.

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 21:07
by Lord S
infinity8ball- metallord99
CowInAPie- metallord99
nickjb3- metallord99
Firestorm94- metallord99
Flatley- metallord99
metallord99- nickjb3

metallord99 was the Vampire. Well done people.

Remarkably (and probably due to neoteny) only one innocent died.

The roles were:

Roles
Neoteny- Vampire
The Doctor- Vampire
metallord99- Vampire

Connect4- Peasant
nickjb3- Peasant

CowInAPie- Sibling
infinity8ball- Doctor and Sibling

Firestorm94- Watchman

Flatley- Butcher

Do you want to know what happened in the Nights?

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 21:15
by nickjb3
Last peasant left alive! w00t. ;)

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 22:01
by connect4
nickjb3 wrote:Last peasant left alive! w00t. ;)


Only dead good guy...

boo...

I knew we should have saved neoteny for later!

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 22:06
by metallord99
Lord S wrote:Do you want to know what happened in the Nights?



yeah, sure.
can be nice to know.

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 22:16
by Firestorm94
Whoo watchman go team!

AAR:
Night1: nothing
Day 1:
I didn't want to cause suspicion by choosing a side so early, so I just NMRed (I thought NMRing was auto-abstain, so I didn't bother to post an abstain)

Night 2: checked connect4, innocent
Day 2: I was convinced by the doctor that infinity was a vampire, so I chose his side. Messaged connect4, told him I was the watchman.

Night 3: checked infinity, innocent. CIAP had claimed they were siblings and since infinity didn't challenge this, that means CIAP is innocent too.
Day 3: messaged CIAP and infinity. Flatley said something about neoteny being watchman, so I decided to take me chances by hinting, via pm, that I was the watchman to him. I had figured that infinity was the medic after he protected CIAP, so I figured he would protect me, since I'm the watchman. This also really helped the next day.

Night 4: checked nickjb3, innocent
Day 4: I pieced together that the NMRs for the vampires were obviously someone who had been NMRing the votes, so I was able to use that as my explanation instead of having to reveal that I was the watchman.

Night 5: Checked Flatley even though it was obvious that both would be seen as evil since I hadn't found the butcher yet. It says Flatley's evil!:twisted:
Day 5: I wasn't attacked which means that my gamble of hinting that I was the watchman to flatley paid off. I was almost 100% sure metallord was the vampire. Poor connect4 :cry:

Great job everyone! :D

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 26 Apr 2009, 23:55
by Lord S
Night Orders

Night 1

not really a turn.

Night 2

metallord99 kill Flatley
The Doctor kill connect4
neoteny NVR

Firestorm94 investigates connect4- innocent

infinity8ball save CowInAPie

Night 3

The Doctor- kill CowInAPie
metallord99- kill CowInAPie
Neoteny- kill CowInAPie

Firestorm94- investigates infinity8ball- innocent
infinity8ball- save CowInAPie

Night 4

metallord99 kill Firestorm94
Neoteny NVR

infinity8ball save Firestorm94
Firestorm94 investigates nickjb3- innocent

Night 5

metallord99 kill connect4

Firestorm94 investigates Flatley-> evil
infinity8ball save Firestorm94

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 27 Apr 2009, 00:26
by CowInAPie
Good game folks!

Re: Mafia 2nd game (proper)

PostPosted: 27 Apr 2009, 02:14
by infinity8ball
BOOYEAH! Batting 1000!!! Guess it's good I'm going host for next game, otherwise the mafia would kill me outright out of principle!

GGA!