Mafia II game (proper)

[Flatley]

I'm going to vote for nickjb3, because it seems no one else will consider anyone besides metallord99 and myself, as we have been consistently pragmatic.

But the question before you all is: why him and not me (or metallord99)? All the evidence metallord had presented against me can easily be applied onto metallord99, as well (and vice-versa, except the connect4 thing). In truth, I actually don't think metallord IS a vampire. If I had to point the finger at anybody, it would be nickjb3, as he had been backing The Doctor's pick in Day 1. But I should reiterate what metallord said: the only people we know aren't vampires are infinity8ball and CIAP, because we accept that they are siblings AND we accept that they aren't vampires (because, after all, four vampires out of nine people makes for an absurdly difficult challenge). We also know that The Doctor, Connect 4, and Neoteny are out of the picture, which leaves us with:

metallord99
Flatley
nickjb3
Firestorm94

I'd say it's all but certain that one of we four are vampires. I can also say that I am fairly confident that Firestorm94 is NOT a vampire. That leaves myself, metallord99, and nickjb3. Now, I know I'm not a vampire. I also know that none of you would expect me to say otherwise, whether it be true or not. But I do know something else: I am not a peasant, either.

Let me put this to you, Infinity (and to the rest of you, too): you suspect that Metallord99 could be a vampire because connect4 verbally sparred with him. You also suspect I am a vampire because I did not aggressively go after anybody, waiting (as I have said) to have things play out before casting a vote. But why don't you even suspect nick, who started off in The Doctor's camp? Maybe you know something I don't. But I definitely don't know what I don't, and I'm not willing to axe Metallord99 just because you're convinced it had to be one of the two people who abstained from voting. If you can tell me why you are absolutely certain nickjb3 is NOT a vampire (whether it be here or via PM), then I will cast my vote for metallord99, and we'll call it a game.

One last thing: on Day Two, I cast my vote for nickjb3, as did three other people: connect4 (deceased, peasant), metallord99 (alive, unknown), and CIAP (alive, assumed to be a sibling, and survivor of a vampire attack). One person voted for The Doctor: infinity8ball. And three people voted for infinity8ball: The Doctor (deceased, vampire), Firestorm94 (alive, unknown), and nickjb3 (alive, unknown). Make what you will of that.

And I am going to bed now, and will not be up for at least ten hours, so let's please not read into my silence.

[Firestorm94]

I'm going to change my vote to Metallord99 I'll explain why after we win.

[Flatley]

I will be changing my vote to metallord99. Certain parties can be pretty convincing.

[metallord99]

from those 2 last posts, I can only assume that Firestorm is the Watchman. ever considerred I mat be the butcher?

Flatley you raised a very good argument so I'll vote for nickjb3.

[Firestorm94]

ever think that Flatley might be the butcher?

[Flatley]

I'm sure the thought has crossed his mind more than once. I'm just glad other people considered it, too.

[Firestorm94]

Anyway, if Flatley's lying, he'll just die next turn.

[metallord99]

Anyway, if Flatley's lying, he'll just die next turn.

everybody said that. you are taking it too lightly killing an innocent, like it's nothing.

[Firestorm94]

It's a game, and I'm not killing an innocent, I'm killing a vampire.

[metallord99]

This is a game