Page 1 of 1

HELP! SOLVED

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 07:41
by sleepyjim
How does a supported unit fail when taking over a single unit?

Here is last move, talking about England taking Swee from Germany: https://www.playdiplomacy.com/game_hist ... =O&gdate=7

This is a big bug.....

Game 153917

Re: HELP!

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 07:47
by sleepyjim
Moves resolver has it right but game did not:
ENGLAND
Skagerrack SUPPORT Denmark to Sweden -> resolved
Picardy HOLD -> resolved
Denmark MOVE Sweden -> resolved
Mid-Atlantic Ocean HOLD -> resolved
North Sea HOLD -> resolved

FRANCE
Brest HOLD -> resolved
Paris HOLD -> resolved
Spain HOLD -> resolved
Burgundy HOLD -> resolved
Portugal HOLD -> resolved

ITALY
Greece HOLD -> resolved
Trieste HOLD -> resolved
Ukraine HOLD -> resolved
Vienna HOLD -> resolved
Ionian Sea HOLD -> resolved

GERMANY
Ruhr HOLD -> resolved
Kiel HOLD -> resolved
Belgium HOLD -> resolved
Sweden MOVE Denmark -> Dislodged by 'f den - swe'
London HOLD -> resolved

AUSTRIA
Serbia HOLD -> resolved

TURKEY
Bulgaria HOLD -> resolved
Aegean Sea HOLD -> resolved
Black Sea HOLD -> resolved

RUSSIA
Sevastopol HOLD -> resolved
Rumania HOLD -> resolved
Gulf of Bothnia MOVE Sweden -> Attack broken by 'f den - swe'
Warsaw HOLD -> resolved
Budapest HOLD -> resolved

Re: HELP!

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 07:54
by AKFD
That's a big mistake.

Denmark had a force of 2.
Sweden had a force of 1.

Yeah, tested it once again... Sweden has to be dislodged.

Re: HELP!

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 08:11
by machor
There is no mistake. Kiel supported Sweden to Denmark, that means it was 2 vs 2 strenght, ergo bounce.

Re: HELP!

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 09:43
by sleepyjim
SOB!!! I never say that...Man I wish I had your eyes.....

Thanks


Jim

PS is it wrong for me to wish there was a glitch?

LOL

Re: HELP! SOLVED

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 09:49
by machor
No problem, I'm glad to help.

sleepyjim wrote:
PS is it wrong for me to wish there was a glitch?



Haven't we all been there? ;)

Re: HELP! SOLVED

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 10:02
by Caladrius
Yeah 2 v 2 so nothing moves.

Game order was Kiel supporting Sweden to Denmark not Kiel hold.

Looks like one hell of a game though!

Re: HELP! SOLVED

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2019, 16:14
by super_dipsy
Thought it might be fun to check up when the last bug was in the adjudication system (the Judge).

Last bug was found in 2013 for normal games, although there was one found in the 1900 variant a couple of years back :D

Re: HELP! SOLVED

PostPosted: 31 Mar 2019, 00:02
by condude1
This tactic's my BANE. It makes it a lot harder to guarantee centers, since you have to guess whether they're going to cut support or go for that bounce. Also really instructive in general, since it pops up in a lot of positions.