Page 1 of 1

Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 18 May 2020, 21:10
by adebruyn666
Hi,

We're playing a game among friends. One surrendered, and was replaced by a new player, but no one knows who it is. Well, no one admits knowing who it is.

The game is password protected, so it's unlikely someone showed up without invitation, or guessed the password. Yet, the new player does not communicate, except a few short sentences in English (the whole game is French speaking) and posts his/her orders at off hours (we all live in Belgium, he posts at 4 AM).

The password protection does not disappear when someone surrenders, right?

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 18 May 2020, 21:18
by V
adebruyn666 wrote:Hi,

We're playing a game among friends. One surrendered, and was replaced by a new player, but no one knows who it is. Well, no one admits knowing who it is.

The game is password protected, so it's unlikely someone showed up without invitation, or guessed the password. Yet, the new player does not communicate, except a few short sentences in English (the whole game is French speaking) and posts his/her orders at off hours (we all live in Belgium, he posts at 4 AM).

The password protection does not disappear when someone surrenders, right?


Yes, the password does cease to function in a standard rank/norank game, when a surrender replacement occurs.
In a “friends” game it doesn’t, but it sounds like you are playing a ranked game amongst friends.
“Tournament” games now retain their password protection too, but not an ordinary ranked game.

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 18 May 2020, 22:44
by adebruyn666
Damn it. It means a stranger has joined our game.

Then we probably need to unrank 175691. "Massacre Masqué." (it's an anonymous game, but everybody knows that I play in it, so revealing my identity is not a big deal). Because we were all friends playing in the privacy of a password-protected game, we all agreed that some rules of the website could be bent:

- All negotiations in the game take place in French, and the game description did not mention it.
- Some players don't even speak English, which puts the newcomer as a distinct disadvantage.
- I haven't, but I suspect some of my friends have been negotiating outside the website interface (phone, etc.). Since none of us were at a disadvantage (we all know each other), I didn't really insist much to enforce that rule.

Now that we have someone outside our friends' circle, I think this is wrong to keep it ranked, and very unfair for the newcomer.

I'm sorry about that. We ignored the password-lifting rule. Otherwise we would have kept it a Friends game (we just wanted to spice it up).

Who should I write to to make the request?

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 18 May 2020, 23:22
by V
adebruyn666 wrote:Damn it. It means a stranger has joined our game.

Then we probably need to unrank 175691. "Massacre Masqué." (it's an anonymous game, but everybody knows that I play in it, so revealing my identity is not a big deal). Because we were all friends playing in the privacy of a password-protected game, we all agreed that some rules of the website could be bent:

- All negotiations in the game take place in French, and the game description did not mention it.
- Some players don't even speak English, which puts the newcomer as a distinct disadvantage.
- I haven't, but I suspect some of my friends have been negotiating outside the website interface (phone, etc.). Since none of us were at a disadvantage (we all know each other), I didn't really insist much to enforce that rule.

Now that we have someone outside our friends' circle, I think this is wrong to keep it ranked, and very unfair for the newcomer.

I'm sorry about that. We ignored the password-lifting rule. Otherwise we would have kept it a Friends game (we just wanted to spice it up).

Who should I write to to make the request?


PM any of the moderators & they can change a game to “friends” status to resolve most of the issues.
NoPunIn10Did is probably a good guy to contact & if he couldn’t fix it would definitely know who could.
Best of luck.

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 19 May 2020, 01:10
by adebruyn666
Thanks. Appreciated.

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 19 May 2020, 02:10
by Jack007
I don't know if it's fair to do that. The substituent might have used his rating shield to enter a reputed ranked game. I think the best solution is that you kill him in the game.

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 19 May 2020, 09:09
by adebruyn666
That's meta-gaming. Using our friendship to gang up against another player. This being said, that's what happening. He doesn't speak French, so he's a sitting duck... Not sure what to do.

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 19 May 2020, 11:24
by Jack007
adebruyn666 wrote:That's meta-gaming. Using our friendship to gang up against another player. This being said, that's what happening. He doesn't speak French, so he's a sitting duck... Not sure what to do.


That's not metagaming. Who does not communicate properly, gets killed asap. An old wisdom in Diplomacy. :mrgreen:

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 19 May 2020, 22:19
by condude1
Nah, it's metagaming if you team up on the guy that entered, adebruyn's right. The game shouldn't be ranked in the first place I think? In any case, shoot the mods a PM (you can vote on a pause in the meantime if you want!), and they'll tell you what to do! It's an innocent (and easy to make!) mistake, so they should be nice about it!

Re: Password-protected game and surrender

PostPosted: 20 May 2020, 11:30
by adebruyn666
Agreed. I sent a PM to NoPunIn10Did and suggested to change this game to 'friends'

If another Mod reads this, feel free to jump in. :-)