Page 2 of 2

Re: Moves that Confuse the Move Calculator?

PostPosted: 22 Apr 2020, 20:18
by Charleroi
And, following up on Condude, even if NTH is destroyed, it still cuts the support that Denmark is trying to give.

Re: Moves that Confuse the Move Calculator?

PostPosted: 22 Apr 2020, 20:27
by Shyvve
It's really impossible to resolve these order without knowing the nationality of all units involved.

As to the question of whether Edi can support NTH. Since F NTH was issued a valid move order, it can't receive support in place (should its attempted move bounce). It's interesting to not that if F NTH had been given an illegal move order, that this order would be converted to a Hold order prior to adjudication, thus allowing F Edi s Nth to be valid. Here's an example of that from the Orders Solver:

ENGLAND
North Sea MOVE Baltic Sea -> Illegal order replaced with Hold order
Edinburgh SUPPORT North Sea to HOLD -> resolved

GERMANY
Skagerrack MOVE North Sea -> Bounced
Norway SUPPORT Skagerrack to North Sea -> Supported unit has failed